Opportunity cost exorbitant, but dirt cheap, Institutional Target Date Retirement Funds (TDFs) have multiple “Emperor’s New Clothes” characteristics coupled with beyond Madoff fraud and manipulation. Yet they are supported by Federal regulators, and forced down the throats of advisory/fiduciary professionals. 

Retirement income portfolios comprised of individual common stocks and various types of income purpose securities have existed for decades in privately managed portfolios. Market Cycle Investment Management (MCIM) programs are a classic, high quality example…similar to the employer pension plans that thrived in years past. 

Wall Street’s newest “head candy” is a brilliantly named “fund of funds” that satisfies regulatory cost emphasis; but they don’t provide meaningful retirement income? 

This from a major provider’s 2015 TDF product description page:

  • “(Our) Target Date Retirement Funds offer a diversified portfolio within a single fund that adjusts its underlying asset mix over time. The funds provide broad diversification while incrementally decreasing exposure to equities and increasing exposure to bonds as each fund’s target retirement date approaches.”
  • “The funds continue to adjust for approximately seven years after that date until their allocations match that of (our) Target Retirement Income Fund…. (Our) 2015 Fund invests in five index funds, holding approximately 55%… in equities and 45% in bonds… Consider this fund if you’re planning to retire between 2013 and 2017.”
  •  MCIM portfolios adjust the asset allocation over time, but they place about five times as much spending money in retiree checking accounts. True retirement programs are income focused.

    Here’s the 11/05 content of the company’s 2015 TDF, with an Expense Ratio (ER) = 0.16%:

    Total Stock Market Index Fund ……………….29.3% (3909 stocks*)  (yield = 1.8%) (ER= .17%)
    Total International Stock Index Fund ……….19.4% (6118 stocks*)  (yield = 0%) (ER = .22%)
    Total Bond Market II Index Fund ……………..30.0%  (yield = 2.1%) (ER = 0.10%)
    Total International Bond Index Fund…………12.8%  (yield = 0.9%) (ER = 0.23%)
    Short Term Inflation-Protected Index Fund…8.5%  (yield = 0.7%) (ER = 0.20%)

    Print Friendly, PDF & Email